300 words on 9/11
September 11, 2012 Leave a comment
There were moments on that day 11 years ago when the United States was seen as something other than a military or economic superpower. It was seen as a nation of vulnerable citizens: Americans were at one and the same time confused, brave, scared and generous, defying simplistic Hollywood stereotypes of what is a complex, multi-faceted country. As I sat in my apartment in Austin, Texas and watched the buildings burn and collapse, it seemed that a threshold had been crossed, and that claims that “things would never be the same,” while painfully clichéd, contained a grain of truth. It is (and was) naïve to think that the events of September 11, 2001 would convert the United States from military bully to benevolent protector, but that is not what most people I knew thought. Not even close. What did seem possible, at least, was that an element of reflexivity would be injected into the American psyche and, in turn, US geo-politics. The US had global goodwill on its side (a rare commodity), and the question was how the US might utilize that goodwill.
It is both tragic and ironic, therefore, that state violence and a curtailment of fundamental freedoms at home and abroad has been the Bush/Obama response to the violent “attacks on freedom” of September 11, 2001. From Abu Ghraib, to Guantamamo, to the Patriot Act, to Afghanistan, to “extraordinary rendition”, to waterboarding, to drone killings, to Bradley Manning to surveillance, the America of September 11, 2012 is a less free, more violent country than it was 11 years ago. The unselfish, collectivist mentality of the people of New York that so impressed the world was quickly, predictably usurped by all-too-familiar US global realpolitik based on economics, individualism and repression. This is a sad anniversary, for lots of reasons.